Kennedy v. Markey is no Pressley v. Capuano

The Topline

On Saturday, Representative Joe Kennedy formally announced his campaign to challenge Senator Ed Markey in the Democratic primary. Rumors of a Kennedy run have been swirling since earlier this summer, and with them comparisons to Ayanna Pressley’s successful primary bid against Mike Capuano. While both Pressley and Kennedy represent a generational shift, the similarities end there. If Pressley ran at Capuano from the left, Kennedy and the district he represents are a little more to the center than Markey and the state as a whole.

The 7th is a bit of an outlier in Massachusetts politics. It is the state’s only majority-minority district by residential population (its registered voters are still majority white). An MPG analysis of voter file data finds that registered voters in the 7th are 53% white 58% under the age of 45, and 51% registered Democrats. Statewide, voters are 84% white, 42% under age 45, and 32% registered Democratic. The 4th district, which Kennedy currently represents, is a little whiter, older, and less Democratic still.As the party registration statistics suggest, the 7th is by far the most liberal district in the state. Take stock of its elected representatives from Pressley to State House reps and even Boston City Councilors, and you’ll name some of the most liberal figures in Massachusetts politics. The Cook Political Report Partisan Voting Index measures how each district performs at the presidential level compared to the national average. The 7th is the most Democratic district in the state by far (and the 15th most in the entire country), with a PVI of D+34. Kennedy’s 4th, by contrast, is a D+9. Ed Markey’s old district, now represented by Rep. Katherine Clark, has a PVI of D+18.

The ideology of the state’s delegation roughly aligns with the partisan lean of their districts. According to GovTrack, which analyzes Congressional voting records from the most recent Congress, Kennedy is solidly in the ideological middle of the Democratic caucus as a whole. He’s actually the third most conservative member from the Massachusetts, after Seth Moulton and Richard Neal. While no data is yet available for Ayanna Pressley, the member she beat, Michael Capuano, was the third most liberal member of the delegation, after Clark and Jim McGovern.

Meanwhile, GovTrack ranks Ed Markey is the 5th most liberal member of the entire Senate, even farther to the left than Elizabeth Warren. That data doesn’t account for his co-sponsoring the Green New Deal, which has earned him the endorsement of many state environmental group and progressive firebrand Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez.

These ideological rankings suggest the 2020 senate race will be a very different campaign than the 2018 MA-7 tilt. Typically, a challenger runs to the left of an incumbent, banking on turnout from hardcore partisans. So it was with Pressley and Capuano. Here, the roles are reversed. Senator Markey is the more liberal candidate, while Kennedy comes into the race with a more middle-of-the-road record (for a Massachusetts Democrat), and from a slightly less Democratic leaning part of the state.

Moreover, Kennedy has something that Pressley never did: a lead in the polls. A recent Suffolk University / Boston Globe poll shows Kennedy with a 14-point lead over Markey in a head-to-head match up among primary voters. While 29% of voters say they are undecided, Kennedy’s name recognition rivals Markey’s, and his favorables are better than the sitting Senator’s. Famously, Ayanna Pressley proved that polls, especially well out from election day, can be overcome. But a year out from the primary Kennedy has quite a head start.

Ever since Seth Moulton knocked off the scandal-damaged John Tierney in 2014, young Massachusetts Democrats have been emboldened to toss party decorum aside in the name of vitality. Just as Pressley’s race was not seen as a repeat of Moulton’s performance, nor should Kennedy be viewed as a rerun of Pressley’s race. Each campaign has its own players, terrain, challenges, and opportunities. A state as blue as Massachusetts, it’s easy to paint with a broad brush, but the candidate who understands the subtle shading of the state’s Democrats may eventually win the day.


This week on The Horse Race, Stephanie presents her takeaways from the Massachusetts Democratic Convention. The event was held prior to Kennedy’s announcement that he will run against sitting Senator Ed Markey, but Stephanie pointed out that there’s one challenger already “doing the work for him,” in Brookline labor attorney Shannon Liss-Riordan, who called to get corporate money out of Washington.

There’s news coming from the Secretary of State’s office, after Bill Galvin came out in support of an initiative petition that would effectively overhaul our primary elections system. Chris Lisinski of the State House News Service drops by to explain the situation

MassINC Polling Group Research Director Rich Parr reports from Western Massachusetts, where he has witnessed concerted effort from disparate communities throughout the region who’ve joined forces to advocate for better, more expansive transit.


FiveThirtyEight has Trump job approval at 43%, with 54% disapproving.

Elizabeth Warren has been gaining in national Democratic primary polls, and now she has taken a slight lead in Iowa, according to a new CNN / Des Moines Register poll, conducted by the guru of Iowa polling Ann Selzer.

Read More…

Meet The Authors

Maeve Duggan

Chief Operating Officer, MassINC

Rich Parr

Senior Research Director, The MassINC Polling Group

Our sponsors